I had AI check my site for accessibility. Two of its ten findings were wrong.

I had Claude check this site against WCAG 2.2. Eight of its ten findings were real. Two were wrong, and both for the same reason. Here’s how to check your own site.

Ink etching of a jeweler's loupe standing on a sheet of paper with a short column of hand-drawn check marks, with the loupe colored rust.

Last night I had Claude check this site for accessibility. It loaded my 17 most-visited pages in a browser, ran a standard checker against WCAG 2.2, and came back with ten findings and a grade of B.

Two of the ten were wrong. It said my links to Forbes open a new tab without warning. They do warn. Each link has hidden text that a screen reader reads out: “opens in a new tab.” It also said a chart in one of my essays had no description of what it shows. It had one.

Both mistakes had the same cause. The check read what shows on screen. The text that solved both problems is hidden on screen and only read aloud by a screen reader. So the check couldn’t see it.

Claude caught both when it opened each one to make the fix. If I’d handed the list to someone to work through, they would have changed things that were already right.

The other eight were real. A light email field that was hard to see. A menu arrow too small to click. Some headings that skipped a level. Fixing them took less than an hour, and the site now grades A.

One more thing surprised me. The first check covered 17 pages. After the fixes, I had it check all 57. It found two more posts with the same heading problem it had already fixed elsewhere. Checking every page took a few minutes. There was no reason to check only a sample.

How to check yours

  1. Run a free checker on your most important pages. WebAIM’s WAVE is the easiest to start with. Your web team may prefer the axe DevTools extension.
  2. Before you fix anything, open each finding and look at the page. Is the problem really there?
  3. Then check every page, not just the busy ones. Pages built from the same template usually share the same problems.
  4. Listen to one page with a screen reader. On a Mac, press Cmd+F5 to turn on VoiceOver. No checker tests this.

Look at each finding yourself before anyone starts fixing.

More on this: Paid media and AI search, where I make the same point about ad platforms that grade their own results.

Written by Aaron Edgell

Growth executive. Builder. Writer.

Get new essays and notes by email.

One email when I publish something new.

Previous: