A WORKING VIEW

What happens to paid media when AI answers first?

People now ask an AI before they search, and the AI answers before anyone clicks. Ads are moving into those answers, the platforms are taking over the buying, and the AI writes its own description of your company. I think paid media spend stays, but the work moves from running campaigns to managing what these systems learn from and checking whether their numbers are true.

Updated November 19, 2026. I revise this page as the evidence changes.

Two phone screens from Google's demo of ads in AI Mode. Left: a Sponsored ad for a smart home fragrance diffuser with Gemini's own summary under it. Right: a Sponsored Duolingo listing inside a list of recommended language apps.
Ads inside Google’s AI Mode. Left: the brand writes one line, and Gemini adds its own summary, which mentions a downside. Right: the ad sits inside a list of recommendations. From Google’s demo videos, May 2026 (Google).

My current view, in four points

What are these systems learning from us, and how would we know if they’re wrong?

WHAT CHANGED IN 2026

AI answers became an ad market in under a year.

OpenAI started showing ads in ChatGPT in February. Google opened its AI Mode to ads through the campaigns advertisers already run. Here is where things stand.

CHATGPT ADS

100,000+

Advertisers have run campaigns on ChatGPT since ads launched in February 2026.

OpenAI, October 2026

AI SEARCH VOLUME

About 1/5

ChatGPT’s search-like queries compared with Google’s, by OpenAI’s count. Outside estimates run 7.5% to 12%.

Big Technology and Forbes, November 2026

AUTOMATED BUYING

+16%

Median change in cost per acquisition after turning on Google’s AI Max, in a study of 250+ accounts.

Smarter Ecommerce, 2026

Spend is growing fast. Proof that it works is not.

2026 timeline

What happened, month by month.

Google and OpenAI each made a major ad move almost every month this year.

GoogleOpenAI (ChatGPT)

Sources are listed at the bottom of this page.

  1. Jan 2026 · GoogleGoogle starts a pilot for deals inside AI Mode answers (Direct Offers).
  2. Feb 9 · OpenAIChatGPT starts showing ads to free and low-cost users in the U.S.
  3. Mar 26 · OpenAIOpenAI says ChatGPT ads passed a $100 million annual run rate in six weeks.
  4. Apr 15 · GoogleGoogle’s AI Max leaves beta. Older Search features are set to fold into it.
  5. May 5 · OpenAIOpenAI opens a self-serve Ads Manager, adds cost-per-click bidding and a tracking pixel.
  6. May 20 · GoogleGoogle tests new ad formats inside AI Mode, including an ad with a chat agent in it.
  7. Jul · GoogleGoogle says 500,000+ advertisers use AI Max.
  8. Aug 31 · OpenAIChatGPT ads pass a $1 billion annual run rate.
  9. Oct 21 · OpenAIChatGPT ads reach 89 countries. OpenAI says 100,000+ advertisers have run campaigns.

01

Your data decides what the system learns

The question to ask

What are we telling the system counts as a win?

When the platform makes the buying decisions, the data you send back is the main thing you still control.

Automated buying

The platform runs the auction. You control what it learns from.

The platform decides

  • Which searches and chats your ad shows on
  • Much of the ad copy, plus the AI’s own summary
  • Where it runs: Search, AI answers, video
  • The bid in each auction
  • The results report it gives you

You still control

  • What counts as a win: customers, not form fills
  • The real outcomes you send back
  • Brand and negative exclusions
  • The website content the AI reads and quotes
  • Budget caps and your own tests

Google says more than 500,000 advertisers use AI Max, which picks the searches, adjusts the ad copy, and chooses the landing page. (Shopifreaks) On ChatGPT, OpenAI’s system makes all delivery decisions. (OpenAI)

So what you call a conversion matters more than any bid setting. A form fill is easy to get. A paying customer is what you want. Send back the outcome you actually care about, even if it takes longer to arrive.

If you get this wrongThe system gets very good at finding the wrong thing.

02

Ads move into the answer

The question to ask

What control are we giving up to get into these placements?

Google and OpenAI now both sell ads inside or right under AI answers. The screenshot at the top of this page shows two of Google’s new formats.

Only campaigns using AI Max, broad match, Shopping, or Performance Max qualify for these spots. Exact and phrase match campaigns without AI Max don’t. (Adtrak)

Google is also testing an ad with a chat agent inside it. In its demo, a prospective student asks a business school about programs and fills out an inquiry form without leaving Google. (Google) If that ships widely, the first conversation with a customer happens on Google’s page, answered from your website.

On ChatGPT, ads appear below an answer when a sponsored product fits the conversation. Only users on the free and lowest-cost plans see them. They don’t show to users under 18, or next to health, mental health, or political topics. (PPC Land) OpenAI now rewrites ads too. Since October 30, it adapts headlines and descriptions to each conversation by default, and you don’t see each version before it runs. You can opt out. (OpenAI)

If you get this wrongYou accept these trade-offs without ever deciding them.

03

Check the numbers yourself

The question to ask

Would we trust this result if we hadn’t designed the test?

The platforms grade their own results, and independent data doesn’t always match.

Who grades the results

Google’s numbers and an outside study agree on volume. They don’t agree on cost.

More conversions or revenue

Google says+15%
Outside study+13%

Change in cost per acquisition

Google saysabout flat
Outside study+16%
In the outside study of 250+ accounts, return on ad spend ranged from 35% worse to 42% better than before. Only about 1 campaign in 5 stayed within its original target.

Google: AI Max or Performance Max campaigns, about the same return on ad spend (Shopifreaks, July 2026). Outside study: Smarter Ecommerce, medians, reported by AI Digital.

One reason is brand searches. Without exclusions, AI Max can take searches your existing brand campaign would have won for less, and count them as its own. Reported results improve. New customers don’t. (AI Digital)

ChatGPT has the opposite problem: too little data. At launch there was no tracking pixel, and in the spring agencies said they couldn’t yet show business results. (eMarketer) OpenAI added a pixel and a conversions API by May. (OpenAI) The first outside numbers aren’t encouraging. A working paper found US visits from ChatGPT ads earned shops $0.89 per session, against $2.45 for Google search ads. The authors call it descriptive, not causal, and OpenAI says it covers an early period. (Search Engine Journal)

So I put more weight on tests I design myself: holdout groups and geographic splits, measured against revenue rather than clicks.

If you get this wrongYou raise spend based on a number the seller reported.

04

Paid and organic are one plan

The question to ask

When someone asks an AI about us, what does it say, and where does it get that?

The same content now feeds the free answer, the paid placement, and the AI’s description of you.

Google now shows an AI-written summary on many brand searches, and the brand doesn’t control what it says. (Google is writing its own description of your company) ChatGPT handles a growing share of search-like questions, and OpenAI now reports to companies how often it cites their sites. (ChatGPT now gets a fifth as many searches as Google; ChatGPT will now tell you how often it mentions your company)

This changes who owns what. An ad’s chat agent answers from your website. If your pages don’t answer buyers’ questions, the agent can’t either. And Google only puts your ad in a list of recommendations when you fit that list. Search, content, and paid media need one owner and one list of the questions buyers ask.

If you get this wrongYou pay for a spot next to an answer that leaves you out.

Still open

Where I could be wrong

These are the points where the evidence is weakest, or most likely to change. I’ll update this page when it does.

01Automation might just winIf careful tests show AI Max adds customers at the same cost, the case for heavy guardrails gets weaker.
02ChatGPT ads may not lastThe 100,000 figure counts everyone who ever ran a campaign, not who is running one now. (PPC Land) One panel of 41,961 US ChatGPT conversations found only 6.9% involved researching a purchase, against more than 15% of Google searches in an earlier study by the same firm. (PPC Land)
03Paid plans never see adsIf your buyers skew toward paid ChatGPT plans, the audience you can reach is smaller than it looks.
04A form inside the ad has a costA form inside Google’s ad may raise volume. It also gives Google the first conversation and the data from it.

NOTES

What I’ve written on this

SOURCES

SUBSCRIBE

Get new writing by email.

Essays and notes on work, growth, and whatever else I’m thinking through. You get one email when I publish something new.